New York
Cnn
–
Almost a month after Target said it is ending some diverse programs, capital and its involvement (Dei), the company is facing reactions from customers, heirs of one of its founders and civil rights activists.
On January 24, at Trump’s presidency, Target announced that he was eliminating employment goals for minority employees, ending an executive committee focused on racial justice and making further changes to his diversity initiatives. Target said there was a new strategy called “Bulseye belonging”, which he introduced for the first time last year, and the company remained committed to “creating a sense of belonging to our team, guests and communities”. Target also emphasized the need for “step in step with the emerging outer landscape”.
Target is one of the dozens of Fortune 500 companies that have returned to Dei in response to conservative court decisions, pressure from activists and right -wing legal groups, and, more recently, the Trump administration threats to investigate what characterizes like ” illegal dei, “including possible criminal cases against companies.
But no company has faced a strong blow from Dei’s supporters as a target.
Target is under more heat than companies like Walmart, John Deere or Tractor Supply because it went further in its dei efforts, and it has a more progressive customer base than those companies.
The return of Dei i Target “seems to be quite arbitrary, based on the current political situation,” said Shreyans Goenka, a Virginia Tech marketing professor who studies how political beliefs affect consumer choices. “When brands become arbitrary in their social causes – supporting Dei today, restoring it tomorrow – it leads to unstable positioning and it makes the brand look unauthorized.”
Target was a leading lawyer for Dei programs in the business world in the years after George Floyd was killed by police in the city of Minneapolis in 2020. Target also spent years building a public reputation as a progressive employer for LGBTQ issues. The company publicly supported homosexual marriage in 2014 before it was legalized across the country, and was one of the first national sellers to allow transgender employees and clients to choose bathrooms corresponding to their gender identities.
Target also increased efforts to attract new parents and minority clients in recent years and built a strong base of Democrats clients. Democrats are more liked to buy at target and see the most favorable chain, according to surveys and surveys. Target has made a push to open smaller shops in cities and near college campuses, which tend to be more liberal.
It is still too early to say whether public criticism will damage the goal financially or cause sustained damage to the company. But the return of the target Dei movements presents an important challenge for its business and highlights the risks of companies that suddenly depart from diversity initiatives that still enjoy support on the left. Companies have been caught between pursuing efforts to increase diversity and avoid a conservative legal blow.
A former intended executive who spoke under the condition of anonymity for fear of career consequences, said the company is being stuck by customers who think they were “sold a lie”.
“Black people supported target. They went to that space because of what the target had done, “the former executive said.” People are wondering if they were really after this or whether it was marketing stunt. ”
Some friends and family have stopped purchases at target, the person said. “When you lose faith, it’s hard to get back.”
Target change has angered some clients who say the company’s movements have given them a whip.
Following the assassination of George Floyd, Target established an executive committee on racial capital action and change, pledged to increase its black labor power by 20% across the company and committed to spending more than $ 2 billion with businesses black owned by the end of 2025.
Target was honored for “his extraordinary commitment to achieve diversity, equality and inclusion” in 2022 by the Council of Executive Leadership, a prominent organization of global black CEO.
But Target has now changed his message. Its racial capital committee, minority employment promises, and financial commitments for black ownership suppliers are all over, as well as target participation in surveys focused on external diversity such as the human rights campaign, one LGBTQ advocacy group.
Target said he is still committed to incorporating and providing a wide range of products and services, including black and minority -owned products, in a statement to CNN.
“For more than 20 years, Target has prompted our business by building teams with different perspectives and experiences, creating comprehensive work and guest environments that welcome all, and developing strategies that represent American consumers we serve,” he said Target.
Target has said the company was on the right track to fulfill its previous goals of workforce diversity and financial commitments for black suppliers as well.
But some senior target executives and elderly leaders have left the company in recent years, including three out of the target racial executive committee.
Target is hitting on some fronts, and there are signs that the reaction can affect the business.
Anne and Lucy Dayton, the daughters of one of Target’s co -founders, called the actions of the company “A Betrayal” and said they were “shocked and disappointed” by the return of Dei Target in a letter published last week in Los Angeles Times. “Framing, target and others are undermining themselves the principles that have made their companies a success,” the girls said, who are not included in the target.
Target also received nearly threefold the number of social media posts about his Dei changes than Walmart, according to an analysis by The Social Element, a marketing firm.
Most comments have denounced target movement. The goal received at least twice as many negative comments on his moves Dei as positive comments, according to the analysis. Some of the best posts were calls to boycott target or switch to Costco and other sellers who were climbing their Dei programs.
“The feeling has been extremely negative,” said Ashley Cooksley and Linn Frost, CEO of the social element.
Jamal Bryant, a prominent pastor in Atlanta, has called for a 40-day target boycott starting in March. More than 50,000 have signed the online promise.
“We have witnessed a disturbing withdrawal from the initiatives of diversity, equality and involvement (dei) from large corporations,” Petition says. “The biggest insult comes from target.”
Fewer customers also visited Target stores in the week after the company announced its changes to Dei.
Foot traffic in target stores increased each year for four weeks in a row, but fell 4% per year for the week of January 27, three days after the Target announcement, according to Placer.ai, who uses phone location data to pursue visits. Placer.ai said slowing can also be attributed to the weather, economic conditions and other variables. Data for the latest weeks are not yet available.
Other companies changed Dei’s policies in response to legal and political shifts without much blow. Target betting clients will not punish the chain for making similar changes, but badly calculated, said Scott Bisang, a partner in Connected Strategies, a communication firm.
“The goal mistaken their customer base,” Bisang said. The goal “underestimated how they would get creepy people because (the target) saw other companies survive it and pass it on.”
What is strangest, some experts say, is that the target is repeating his mistake to alienate progressive customers.
In 2023, Target faced a right -wing pressure campaign for collecting its pride month goods. Opponents focused their attention on women’s swimsuit sold in target that was described as “friendly” for his ability to hide male genitals. The misinformation spread to the social media that was shown to the children, which was not the case.
The campaign became hostile, with violent threats imposed against target employees and damaged products and shows in stores. Target chose to remove the items that caused the most “unstable” response from opponents, which the company said was made to protect the safety of its workers.
But Target’s response irritated some gay and transgender rights supporters, who said the company withdrew in high pressure. Target’s quarterly sales fell after the month of pride in 2023, though they recovered in the following quarters.
“Target was a voice lawyer and sponsor of pride,” Bisang said. “They had seen warning signs from the withdrawal of LGBTQ last time.”
The big question is whether the reaction and calls of boycott will cause long -term target damage, as Bud Light did, or will fade. In 2023, the Bud Light AB Inbev’s parent company lost as much $ 1.4 billion as sale due to the right -wing response in Bud Light’s short partnership with transgender Dylan Mulvaney.
One of the main reasons Bud Light’s boycott was successful was because it was very easy for clients to replace Coors or Miller without much sacrifice, said Jura Liaukonyte, a marketing professor at Cornell University who studies consumer boycotts.
A boycott against target can be difficult to support because other chains that consumers can pass as Walmart or Amazon have also supported Dei programs. Calls of boycott against Goya Foods for her CEO support for Trump in 2020 also had limited success because many of those who defended for a boycott were not the main consumers of Goya to begin, Liaukonyte said.
“If Target Faces Rain Sales Sales, like Bud Light made, will depend on how much its main buyer base matches the right reaction,” she said, and how appropriate it is for buyers to switch to other stores.